Last week I sat down to read some marketing research. Big company, big library of it. Before the site showed me a single article, it asked me a question.
It wasn’t “Welcome.” Nor was it a row of tabs. The question was simple: What are you solving for today?
I typed an answer. The page rearranged itself around it. Every piece that came back had a little line under it telling me what it was ideal for — before I even clicked. And as I scrolled, a bar followed me down the page that said, “What do you want to explore next?”
The company asking was Google.
The company that built the search box put one on its own front door. And then I went and looked at mine.
Hi, I’m Jeff Payne. You’re listening to The Jeff Payne Show, Episode 115: Think Like Google — Your Home Page Is a Menu. There’s a Question.
Open your company’s website right now. I’ll wait.
Odds are, the top of it is a menu. About Us. Services. Our Team. Blog. Contact. It was built to describe the company — who you are, what you do, and where you are. It’s a brochure that happens to be online. And it has probably looked that way, give or take a redesign, for ten years.
Now here’s what Google did with its own marketing site — the one it runs for business leaders. It rebuilt the whole thing around the visitor’s question. You tell it what you’re working on, and it builds you a feed. Articles, video, audio, and little swipe-through cards — same idea, three doors. You pick the one that fits your morning. A button says Brief me, and it hands you the short version. Every click teaches it something, and the next thing it shows you is a little closer to what you came for.
And the best of it sits behind a sign-in. Google didn’t lock it to keep you out. It locked it to find out who you are.
Here’s why this matters. It’s not “Google personalizes.” Google has personalized things for years.
It’s this. The company whose entire business is knowing what people are looking for decided that the right first move on its own website is to ask. Not to present. Not to organize its library and let you browse. To ask what you’re solving for, then get out of the way.
That’s a statement about where attention lives now. A buyer landing on your site is not there to learn about you. They are in the middle of a problem, and they are checking whether you are the answer. Every second you spend describing yourself is a second they spend deciding you’re not the answer.
Look at that Ideal for line again. It’s a promise, made before the click. “This piece is for a person trying to do this.” A menu makes the visitor do the sorting. A label does the sorting for them. One respects their time; the other spends it.
And the feed that adapts — think about what that does to content. In a feed that learns from every click, a piece nobody chooses stops being shown. It doesn’t get a bad review. It disappears. That means only the content people actually want survives when they’re trying to get something done. Slop starves. Google didn’t write that rule. It’s what happens when the visitor controls what comes next.
The question isn’t whether you can build what Google built. You can’t, and you don’t need to. The question is whether your website is organized around what you want to say or around what your buyer came in asking.
Three things. You can check all three today.
One. Read the top of your home page and ask: is this a menu or a question? If a stranger with a problem landed here, does the page address the problem, or does it hand them a directory?
Two. Pick your five most important pages. Can you write an Ideal for line under each one — “ideal for a buyer who is trying to do this” — in one sentence? If you can’t, the page was written for you, not for them.
Three. When someone reaches the bottom of a page, what happens? Google puts a bar there that says what you want to explore next. On most sites, the bottom of the page ends the conversation.
That’s the move. Stop designing for the visit. Design for the next question.
Here’s your self-audit for the week. Is your home page a menu or a question? Do your pages state who they’re for before anyone clicks? And when a buyer runs out of pages, do you ask what’s next — or say goodbye?
I pulled 15 ideas from what Google built — 15 ways to think like Google about your own site. They’re in the show notes and on the blog at jeffpayne.net.
That’s it for this episode. I’m Jeff Payne. See you tomorrow.
Think like Google: Your home page is a menu. Theirs is a question.
Last week, I sat down to read some marketing research. Before the site showed me a single article, it asked me a question: What are you solving for today?
Not, “Welcome.” Not a row of tabs. A question. I typed an answer, and the page rebuilt itself around it. Every piece that returned carried a small label — “Ideal for…” — that told me who it was written for before I clicked.
As I scrolled, a bar followed me down the page: What do you want to explore next?
The company asking was Google. The company that built the search box put a search box on its own front door. And then I went and looked at mine.
Your home page is a brochure that happens to be online
Pull up your company’s website. Odds are, the top of the page is a menu: About Us, Services, Our Team, Blog, Contact. It was built to describe the company — who you are, what you do, and where you are. Give or take a redesign, it has looked that way for 10 years.
Now look at what Google did with the marketing site it runs for business leaders. It rebuilt the whole thing around the visitor’s question. You say what you’re working on; it builds you a feed. Articles, video, audio, and swipe-through cards — the same idea offered through three doors.
A “Brief me” button hands you the short version. Every click teaches it something, and the next thing it shows you is a little closer to what you came for.
And the best of it sits behind a sign-in. Google didn’t lock it to keep you out. It locked it to learn who you are.
Google didn’t lock its best content to keep you out. It locked it to find out who you are.
The lesson isn’t “Google personalizes”
Google has personalized things for years. The lesson is sharper than that. The company whose entire business is knowing what people are looking for decided that the right first move on its own website is to ask. Not to present. Not to organize its library and let you browse. To ask what you’re solving for and then get out of the way.
That’s a statement about where attention lives now. A buyer landing on your site isn’t there to learn about you. They’re in the middle of a problem and checking whether you’re the answer. Every second you spend describing yourself is a second they spend deciding you’re not the answer.
Look at that Ideal for line again. It’s a promise made before the click: this piece is for someone trying to do this. A menu makes the visitor do the sorting. A label does the sorting for them.
One respects their time; the other wastes it.
A menu makes the visitor do the sorting. A label sorts for them.
Slop Starves
Think about what an adaptive feed does to content. In a feed that learns from every click, content nobody chooses stops being shown. It doesn’t get a bad review. It disappears. Only content people actually want survives when they’re trying to get something done.
Google didn’t write that rule. It happens when you never control what comes next — and, increasingly, on every platform and in every AI answer, visitors are.
The question isn’t whether you can build what Google built. The question is whether your website is organized around what you want to say or around what your buyer walked in asking.
15 Ways To Think Like Google
Here are 15 ideas I pulled out of what Google built — none of them require Google’s engineering budget. They require deciding who your website is for.
For every dollar we spend with you we are putting at least 5 back into our pocket AFTER we subtract what we spent.
That’s an amazing cost/benefit that I have never received before in any of our previous marketing endeavors.
Daniel C Goodwin
Provident 1031
Chief Investment Strategist
July 4, 2025
THE MOVE
Three things you can check today.
One. Read the top of your home page and ask: is this a menu or a question? If a stranger with a problem landed here, does the page address the problem or hand them a directory?
Two. Pick your five most important pages. Can you write an Ideal for line under each one — ideal for a buyer trying to do this — in a single sentence? If you can’t, the page was written for you, not for them.
Three. When someone reaches the bottom of a page, what happens? Google places a bar there that asks what you want to explore next. On most sites, the bottom of the page ends the conversation.
Stop designing for the visit. Design for the next question.
Stop designing for the visit. Design for the next question.
Your self-audit
Is your home page a menu or a question?
Do your pages state who they’re for before anyone clicks?
And when a buyer runs out of pages, do you ask what’s next — or say goodbye?
Source: This episode was prompted by the redesigned, AI-driven Think with Google (thinkwithgoogle.com), Google’s site for marketers and business leaders, as experienced firsthand in November 2026. The reading of what it means for a company website is my own.
COMPLETE THE FORM TO
BOOK A STRATEGY CALL
"*" indicates required fields
COMPLETE THE FORM TO
BOOK A STRATEGY CALL
"*" indicates required fields
Subscribe and S—are – WE APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT