11:53 on a Friday night. A form on my screen asks a single question. Who do you write for?
I type: “My team and I write for—”
And I stop.
20+ years in this business. Four words in, and I can’t finish the sentence. Not because I don’t know the answer, but because every answer I can think of sounds like somebody else’s.
That’s where this episode starts.
Hi, I’m Jeff Payne. You’re listening to The Jeff Payne Show, Episode #114: Your Elevator Pitch Is A Filter.
Back in Episode 100, I gave you a move. Ask an AI what your company does, then compare its first sentence with yours.
A lot of you did it. I know because you told me.
What I didn’t tell you is that I did it too. Not to a client. To myself. And what came back wasn’t a pitch. It was a diagnosis.
So today is the follow-up I didn’t plan. What happened when the host ran his own test — and the three things I found that I think are true for every CEO listening.
Here’s the first one. The pitch was already written. I just wasn’t the one who wrote it.
I started where everybody starts. A description of what I do. Services. Categories. The nouns on my website. Every draft was accurate, and every draft was dead.
Then I remembered something a client said to me. He said: marketing is just your introduction.
He meant it as a compliment. What he was telling me was that the thing I sell isn’t what I’m hired for. The marketing gets me in the door. What keeps me in the room is something he could see that I couldn’t — because I was too close to it.
That’s the first finding. Your best positioning sentence is likely in an email from a customer. You’ve read it. You’ve forgotten it. And you’ve overwritten it with an About page.
The second thing I found was in the editing process.
Every time I cut a word, it was the same kind of word. Aligned. Higher revenue. Talent and skill. Results-driven. I cut them because they were vague, but that’s not really why they had to go.
They had to leave because the last vendor on the call used them too.
Think about what a pitch is for. It’s the one moment when a buyer can tell you apart from everyone else vying for their money. And generic words aren’t filler. They’re camouflage. They make you sound like the category instead of the company. The more you use them, the safer you feel — and the less anyone remembers.
Which leads to the third point, and it’s the one I want you to take home.
A pitch is not a hook. A pitch is a filter.
The version I landed on tells some people to leave. It says I work with owner-led businesses where the customer has to trust them before doing business. It says the CEO gets a system that wins, not a vendor who delivers tasks. If you’re looking for a vendor who delivers tasks, that sentence just told you I’m the wrong call. On purpose.
I’ve said for years: people want to buy. They don’t want to be sold to. Every CEO knows the feeling because everyone on earth is coming at you with something to sell. A good pitch is how you stop selling. It says who you’re for, using only the words you would use, and then it gets out of the way so the right person can decide.
That’s what “on mission” means. Not a poster on the wall. A sentence you can say to a stranger without flinching — because it has already made the hard decisions for you.
So here’s what the Friday night actually produced. I’ll give you the whole thing, because I think you should hear what a pitch sounds like after the camouflage is gone.
“Jeff Payne. Marketing is my introduction. Then I become the person in the room who brings the right people together and aligns the ideas, the plan, and the execution — so the CEO gets a system that wins.”
And then the part I didn’t write.
On July 4th of last year, Dan Goodwin at Provident 1031 wrote me a note. Exact words: “For every dollar we spend with you, we are putting at least five back into our pocket.”
That’s the end of my pitch now. Not because it’s a big number. Because it isn’t mine. He said it, dated it, and it has held for a year and a half. The strongest sentence in any pitch is the one a customer wrote.
That’s the whole show in one line, by the way. Proof over proximity. I just finally applied it to myself.
Three questions.
One. Whose words are in your pitch? If every sentence is yours, you’re claiming. Find the customer’s sentence and put it last.
Two. Which words would the last vendor on the call have said as well? Cut those. Every one. What’s left is shorter, and it’s yours.
Three. What does your pitch tell the wrong client to do? If the answer is nothing—if anyone could hear it and say “sure, let’s talk”—it isn’t a pitch yet. It’s a greeting.
A pitch you can’t say without flinching is a lie. Usually, it’s to someone. Usually, you.
I’m Jeff Payne. Say the sentence out loud and see what you cut. Thanks for listening. See you tomorrow.
I ran the Episode 100 test on myself. Here is what it found.
At 11:53 on a Friday night, a form on my screen asked one question:
Who do you write for?
I typed “My team, and I write for—” and stopped. Twenty-plus years in this business, four words in, and I couldn’t finish the sentence. Not because I didn’t know the answer. Because every answer I could think of sounded like somebody else.
Back in Episode 100 I gave you a move: Ask an AI what your company does, and compare its first sentence to yours. A lot of you did it. What I didn’t say is that I did it too — on myself. What came back wasn’t a pitch. It was a diagnosis. This is the follow-up I didn’t plan, and the three findings I think hold for every CEO reading this.
Finding one: the pitch was already written — by a customer
I started where everyone starts. A description of what I do and then the services, categories, the nouns on my own website. Every draft was accurate, and every draft hit the mark.
Then I remembered something a client said to me nearly two years ago: marketing is just your introduction. He meant it as a compliment. What hreallytually telling me wasI’mell ihired for what I sell. Marketing gets me in the door. What keeps me in the room is something he could see and I couldn’t, because I was standing too close to it.
That is the first finding, and I suspect it’s true of your company too. Your best positioning sentence is probably sitting in an email from a customer. You read it once, you were flattered, you forgot it — and then you overwrote it with an About page.
Your best positioning sentence is probably sitting in an email from a customer. You’ve read it. You’ve forgotten it. And you’ve overwritten it with an About page.
Finding two: every word I cut was a word everyone else uses
The second finding showed up in the editing. Every time I struck a word, it was the same kind of word. Aligned. Higher revenue. Talent and skill. Results-driven. I told myself I was cutting them because they were vague. That’s not really why they had to go.
They had to go because the last vendor on the call used them too.
Think about what a pitch is for. It is the one moment a buyer can tell you apart from everyone else who wants their money. The generic words are not filler. They’re camouflage. They make you sound like the category instead of the company. The more you use them, the safer you feel — and the less anyone remembers you.
The generic words aren’t filler. They’re camouflage. They make you sound like the category instead of the company.
Finding three: a pitch is a filter, not a hook
This is the one to take home. The version I landed on tells some people to leave. It says I work with owner-led businesses where the customer has to trust them before they’ll do business. It says the CEO gets a system that wins, not a vendor who delivers tasks. If you’re shopping for a vendor who delivers tasks, that sentence just told you I’m not the right call. On purpose.
I’ve said for years that people want to buy, but they don’t want to be sold. Every CEO knows the feeling, because everyone on earth is coming at you with something to sell. A good pitch is how you stop selling. It says who you’re for, in words only you would use, and then it gets out of the way and lets the right person decide.
That is what “on mission” actually means. Not a poster in the lobby. A sentence you can say to a stranger without flinching, because it already made the hard decisions for you.
What the Friday night produced
Here is the whole thing, because I think you should see what a pitch looks like once the camouflage is gone:
“Jeff Payne. Marketing is my introduction. Then I become the person in the room who brings the right people together and makes the ideas, the plan, and the strategy work — so the business owner or CEO sees their business grow. Daniel Goodwin at Provident 1031 says that for every dollar he spends with me, he gets five back.”
And then the part I didn’t write.
On July 4, 2025, Dan Goodwin at Provident 1031 sent me a note. His exact words: “For every dollar we spend with you, we are putting at least five back into our pocket.”
For every dollar we spend with you we are putting at least 5 back into our pocket AFTER we subtract what we spent.
That’s an amazing cost/benefit that I have never received before in any of our previous marketing endeavors.
Daniel C Goodwin
Provident 1031
Chief Investment Strategist
July 4, 2025
That is the end of my pitch now. Not because it’s a big number — because it isn’t mine. He said it, he dated it, and it has held for a year and a half. The strongest sentence in any pitch is the one a customer wrote. That’s the whole show in one line: proof over proximity. I just finally applied it to myself.
The strongest sentence in any pitch is the one a customer wrote
THREE QUESTIONS
One. Whose words are in your pitch? If every sentence is yours, you’re claiming. Find the customer sentence and put it last.
Two. Which words would the last vendor on the call have also said? Cut those. Every one. What’s left is shorter, and it’s yours.
Three. What does your pitch tell the wrong client to do? If the answer is nothing — if anyone could hear it and say “sure, let’s talk” — it isn’t a pitch yet. It’s a greeting.
A pitch you can’t say without flinching is a pitch that’s lying to someone. Usually you. Say yours out loud. See what you cut.
Sources and notes: Episode 100, “The Seven-Second Company,” was prompted by Brett Fox’s Elevator Test workshop; this episode is its sequel.
Dan Goodwin’s quote is reproduced verbatim from his note of July 4, 2025.
COMPLETE THE FORM TO
BOOK A STRATEGY CALL
"*" indicates required fields
COMPLETE THE FORM TO
BOOK A STRATEGY CALL
"*" indicates required fields
Subscribe and S—are – WE APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT